After the destruction of Vulcan, Starfleet is no longer the same utopian Starfleet audiences have grown to know and love (ignoring their problematic tendencies) from the previous iterations into the franchise. However, Star Trek Beyond, the last film of Abrams' trilogy, happens 3 years before Captain Kirk (takes command of the Starship Enterprise in the Prime timeline. With all of the action and excitement happening in the Prime Universe, here's why the Kelvin Timeline of J.J. Abrams' Star Trek movies is no longer relevant and or advantageous, and why Star Trek 4 should bring the movies' Starship Enterprise crew into the Prime Universe. Interestingly, when interviewed about season 2, co-creator Alex Kurtzman addressed the idea of who might be on the Enterprise, stating I think there will be some surprises there. Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more. Such huge discrepancies have been waved away by fans saying the Discoverys status as a military vessel gave it access to technology other ships of the time didnt have. We need to see more of DSC and hope we will get some good confirmation. Creating the Kelvin timeline was a stroke of genius in a way, and while not being directly linked to the prime timeline, the films have still influenced proceeding additions to the franchise. When CBS and Viacom merged (again), all the rights to Star Trek were under the same corporate umbrella. Thats actually not as easy as you might think to answer, despite what the showrunners and cast might say. The idea floated is that there is a most probable version of reality that happens more than others, despite minor differences. Is Star Trek: Discovery set in the original or the Kelvin timeline? That's interesting, but that does not mesh with anything else in established prime canon. In fact, 2009 film writer and Discovery producer Kurtzman has explained the Prime and Kelvins similarities and improbable coincidences as the timestreams way of trying to mend itself a line that was at one point written for Prime Spock in the movie when he impossibly meets Kelvin Kirk in a cave. They looked quite differently). During the pursuit, both ships were pulled through the black hole left in the wake of the supernova, which sent them back in time. Remember that no one really knew what happened to USS Kelvin? They still have to match what we see. The implication is that there could be numerous Prime and Kelvin realities, basically identical, but separated by a haircut here, or a coffee instead of an Earl Grey there. Heres whats fun about that: the Kelvin timeline doesnt start until 2233. In the Prime timeline, as he says in TWOK, Kirk says that this got him a commendation "for original thinking." After the battle with Khan, the Enterprise crew in the Kelvin timeline set out for their own version of the five-year mission we saw in Star Trek: The Original Series, and three years into that mission, they encountered something interesting (particularly from our perspective as observers), something with a backstory that extended far back into the timeline, before the universes diverged. This also means Spock disappeared into the alternate past, where he died, as mentioned in Star Trek: Beyond. In-universe explanation for why is the TOS-era Enterprise is more austere than the Discovery? You have to respect canon, stated Kurtzman in this interview. Scan this QR code to download the app now. In Into Darkness (2013), Alexander Marcus, leader of the secretive Section 31, finds the SS Botany Bay, stuffed to the rafters full of augmented humans in cryostasis. Yes it was actually in the Motion Picture that we first saw TNG era Klingons. The Kelvin timeline, or "alternate universe Trek", creates a new environment in which the events of the more recent Star Trek films (Star Trek, Into Darkness, Beyond) won't contradict those. Space is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. CANT WAIT to see what comes next!! To make matters worse, both his ship, the experimental Jellyfish, and the Romulan mining ship Narada were pulled into the black holes wake and sent hurtling backwards in time. Then theres the Kelvin timeline which was established in J.J. Abrams first movie when the Romulan, Nero, travelled back from the future and destroyed the USS Kelvin a little under 30 years before TOS originally took place. This version of James T. Kirk was a rebellious young man, joyriding in stolen cars as a teenager and getting into bar fights in his 20s. Yes.September 15, 2017, While author David Mack who was in the loop during Discoverys development also said the shows Prime, while adding that discrepancies will be addressed/resolved., What Anthony said. If that were true, it makes everything we know about Voyager's doctor and the issuea he had with mobility really weird. Star Trek's Prime Timeline Crossed Over With Kelvin On Discovery Star Trek: Discovery season 3 revealed that the 32nd century United Federation of Planets has long been aware of the Kelvin Timeline. As that could just be "modern looks for a dusty timeline" I want to make sure and ask: is Discovery set in the original or the Kelvin timeline? That bit of ugliness behind them, the Enterprise receives its five-year-mission. Kirk et al save the day, of course. Aurora colors: What causes them and why do they vary? But I am working on that. They wanted to retell a story that everyone knew and do it differently, all without breaking the well-respected canon that fans have grown so attached to. In fact, even though Star Trek: The Animated Series isn't itself canon, many concepts introduced in the show became essential parts. It's not just official statements we should accept. Therefore, you can't always derive an exact year from the stardate. But the mod had a shelf life. 3 This image is from the remastered version of the episode. Order of events between Prime and Kelvin timelines. Let me first challenge by saying that if we favor a prime placement, we still need to resolve some problems. And when you know that, it's very difficult to put them in jeopardy in a way that feels fresh or original. It fits w/canon. Throughout Trek, stardates were used to keep time when ships were traveling faster than light. Can a creature that "loses indestructible until end of turn" gain indestructible later that turn. Visit our corporate site. Also: i didn't see the Kor in this show.You know: the Dahar master, an important and honored general in the Federation war, THIS war.. Ok. That's two advancements in one. TOS did have Rec Rooms that were capable of holographic projections but these were more movie-like projections that simulations. In an effort to save the countless shuttles escaping the destruction wrought by Nero, which included a shuttle containing the newborn James Kirk and his mother, George Kirk sacrifices his ship. Its now 2258 and Ambassador Spock emerges from the black hole just in time to be scooped up by Nero, who keeps the Jellyfish and its cache of red matter for himself while abandoning Spock on the frozen planet of Delta Vega. Ok the issue is that we don't know how to compare the 2 fleets. The Naradas captain, Nero decides to use this opportunity to take out his grief on the organization he holds responsible for the ruin of Romulus and, by extension, the death of his family: the Federation. But it's not a mystery to the Starfleet of the future. A change that was probably made because Chekov would otherwise be a 13-year-old during the events . The Kelvin Timeline Is One of Many Alternate Realities in Star Trek. That looks more like TOS dating (which was of course all over the place and not consistent), where the first one given in "Where No Man Has Gone Before" was 1312.4 (2265). Avoiding memory leaks and using pointers the right way in my binary search tree implementation - C++. The attack by Nero that created these two divergent realities happened in 2233, the end of season 1 sees the Discovery make contact with the TOS-era Enterprise in 2257 when Commander Pike is still captain. The story of Star Trek's Kelvin timeline began in the Prime Star Trek universe in the 2380s, when it became clear that the Romulan sun presented a major danger not just to the Romulan Star Empire but to a whole quadrant of the galaxy. In "Despite Yourself" (Discovery, season 1, episode 10), Captain Lorca refers to data, recovered from the mirror universe rebel ship, that describes the Terran Empire's acquisition of the USS Defiant (NCC-1764). And if you're curious to see how the new movies stack up against the classics, check out our Star Trek movies, ranked worst to best article. Is not listing papers published in predatory journals considered dishonest? RELATED: Star Trek: The Klingon Language, Explained. The characters and situations in the movies were off-limits . Because of trademarks it's actually impossible for it to be set in the Kelvin timeline, as far as I understand. However, in the Kelvin timeline, it is Admiral Alexander Marcus who wakes Khan from his slumber. Sure there will be differences. In 2258 and 2259, Admiral Alexander Marcus went to great lengths to pursue this more warlike approach in secret, and he began exploring the galaxy for various resources to use for the defense of Starfleet. See the HEART of @startrekcbs: it's real STAR TREK to its core.September 15, 2017, Theres no arguing that Discovery is Star Trek to its core but theres still so much that doesnt add up. Early Tweets from Anthony Rapp, who plays astromycologist Lieutenant Paul Stamets in the show, seemed to clearly state Discovery is Prime timeline, Yes it is in the Prime timeline. In secret, he blackmails the reawakened Khan to help develop powerful weaponry, as well as warships for the federation. Perhaps from an event yet to happen in season 2 that creates a third timeline, and will finally explain the inconsistencies. The Klingons revised look should have been a revision of TOS era Klingons not modern Klingons. My question is, why does everything not add up correctly? Star Trek: Discovery is set in the original timeline, not in the Kelvin one. Having said all that I must say that the base premise of the series (namely the spore drive) violates so many established threads that while it's very well made show and carefully tied elsewhere - as I point out above - that I basically refuse to watch the series until it is resolved. How do I figure out what size drill bit I need to hang some ceiling hooks? Since we are doing this series in 2016, and all of the other series have been produced [at a time that] isnt as sophisticated as we are now with what we can do production-wise, were going to be reestablishing an entire look for the series not only for the series, but for what we wanted to accomplish with Star Trek beyond this series. Well we have more modern looking Klingons, and the entire race seems to follow that look. the ST:Ent is tied into the TNG timeline, First Contact timeline (which we know wasn't altered in any meaningful way). He figures Kirk will kill, not capture, Khan, thus removing a threat and evidence of Marcus secret project. Best Place For Mods: https://www.gamefront.com/games/bridge-co. Technically the Kelvin timeline and Prime timeline coexist and run concurrently together, so why not other variations? How do you reboot a franchise thats been around more than 50 years old and whose fan base is, shall we say, passionate about the accuracy of its canon? The. Heres how it works. Yet despite his similar trajectory, there are bigger differences in the wider universe. There's a third option: It's post-Enterprise timeline. Unless purely new people were watching the film, there would not be the same amount of drama or suspense, especially when they know how these characters die (and thus know that they dont die in the new film). The Kelvin timeline is rather hit-and-miss among fans of the Star Trek franchise. No holodecks. There were devices called protein resequencers that could make food, essentially organic 3D printers, but these were a world away from the teleporter tech apparently forming Burnhams clothes atom by atom. What this means for us is simple. This is 10 years before Kirk's era and nearly a hundred after Archer. Plus, there are some huge inconsistencies with either timeline beyond the basics of Burnham being Spock's previously unmentioned half-sister, the fundamentally different looking Klingons (especially as this is the peak time for the more ordinary looking Klingons of the TOS, explained by a virus created from augmented human DNA), or the apparent near destruction of the Federation. Why did Pike want Kirk in Starfleet so adamantly? While CBS retained the rights to Star Trek on TV, Paramount was able to hold on to the film rights thanks to the 2009 film. If we aceeptthe Nero-caused upgrades, it's technology the fleet is experimenting with. This wasn't just another reboot, though. In Star Trek Beyond, the Enterprise crew discovers the buried U.S.S. This suggests that the Prime analog of the Kelvin would have been about the size of the Miranda-class, with a crew of around 100. All rights reserved. Reddit, Inc. 2023. back then, the bridge looked much like a (for then) modern naval bridge. If no one has seen Klingons in nearly a hundred years, that would mean not many saw the missed Klingons that Archer barely dealt with. The similarities and differences continue into the second film Star Trek: Into Darkness where audiences are introduced (or perhaps re-introduced) to the one and only Khan Noonien Singh. But let me explain it a bit more. Should storytellers want to revisit it or perhaps do a big-old multiverse crossover like The Flash movie, it might become relevant. The year 2233 is when the Kelvin timeline diverges from the prime timeline. Simply saying it doesn't make it so. Speaking with Sci Fi Wire in 2009, Kurtzman explained, "Yeah, the biggest thing I think we all hiccuped on, just conceptually, when Trek was presented to us was, 'Well, we know how they all died. Remember, Enterprise had a Temporal Cold War with history changes and a huge Xindi war that never happened in the TOS/TNG/DS9/VOY universe. Picard takes place long after the titular character has quit Starfleet, and early on we discover the destruction of Romulus was why. But if were going to get any answers its going to happen in season 2. In the prime timeline, Kirk is the one who awakens him from the cryogenic stasis, and starts a whole series of events that end in one of the best Star Trek films ever made, The Wrath of Khan. But the best stories are going to explain it not write it off. I just ranted about producer statements. The original 'Prime' timeline was started by the Original Series, the Next Generation-era TV shows, and the first ten movies, The alternative 'Kelvin' timeline, meanwhile, was created in . Theres a Prime timeline, a Kelvin one, the Mirror Dimension and more time travelling and universe hopping than several other shows combined. In the Prime Star Trek timeline, James T. Kirk's path to captaining the U.S.S. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. All things considered: Discovery is decent, and, it hits the fan service beats, but, whether they think they are or not, they are doing a story that fits in better if its an extension of the Kelvin timeline rather than a story that neatly fits in to the robustly detailed prime timeline. #StarTrekDiscovery @StarTrekRoom @startrekcbs pic.twitter.com/LJhGhKYwIfOctober 23, 2017. Yes I know. As I mentioned a moment ago, like Docs chalkboard drawing, both the Prime and Kelvin timelines coexist in the same universe, the latter a quantum reality existing alongside the former. As it stands now, the Prime Universe is still the one Star Trek fans need to care about the most. A few comments I read before Star Trek: Discovery premiered indicated it was part of the original timeline, but after seeing the show I'm not 100% sure: many of the consoles we see here are similar to those in the current films.
How To Date Someone Who Likes Space, Fort Bragg Schools Calendar, How To Check Duplicate Values In Json, Articles K